community, pop culture

The Death of A Fandom: Could It Actually Be A Good Thing?

Lunar Dragon" by Manticora - Miorro @ deviantart | Mythical ...

I debated not making this post.

I’m concerned about a lot of things when it comes to the current state of fandoms in the bookish community. I’m concerned as an author, and as a reader.

Basically, the last several weeks have led to two things. One: Everybody who’s decided they still like Harry Potter is being demonized for not wanting to give up a beloved fantasy series they have fond memories of. Two: Everyone who’s decided JK Rowling is an absolutely terrible person, and they’re done with a beloved fantasy series they have fond memories of based solely on their new opinion of the author, are bashing and bullying the folks who took Option One.

Here’s why this state of affairs bothers me a lot: While people are completely entitled to their own perspective — especially when it comes to something so subjective as literature — I don’t like to see an entire body of work, and the readers who loved/love it being treated like total garbage because of the unwise words of said work’s creator.

The weird truth about any sort of art is that it does exist in a sort of separate world from its creators. Honestly, there are many books I’ve enjoyed whose authors I don’t believe I’d meet for coffee — or, in fact, want to get anywhere near in real life. But I can set my feelings about the person aside from my feelings about the work. Maybe most folks can’t do that, I guess?

Enhanced Castle Wallpaper 4K Edition Update : Bloodstained

When it comes to the raging debate over the actual words of JK Rowling, I do think her remarks were generally offensive, but that she didn’t consider them such. Being brutally honest, I truly think she’s so arrogant as to believe she’s an expert on something she knows little about (and don’t ask me how she made that determination).

Do I feel deeply for readers who are aching at what they see as the destruction of one of their favorite series? Yes, I do. Can I also agree with those who are deciding to firmly keep the books and the author in those different realms of existence? Yeah, I can.

I loved Harry Potter. I’ve read all 7 books and seen all 8 movies. There were, of course, some I liked more than others. But although, after seeing a few interviews with Rowling, I didn’t necessarily care for her as a personality, nothing about her writing irked me enough to make a difference.

But a few years ago, as my copies of the novels were wearing out, and we’d seen each of the films at least twice, I decided to pass on getting fancy new editions, or on collecting the DVDs. It wasn’t just that I knew the story start to finish and there was nothing new to discover; I realized that the parts I didn’t care for were really starting to nag at me.

I could write an entire review on which things fell short for me on this series. (Maybe one day I will.) But for now, let’s suffice it to say that I was only satisfied with about 25% of the last book. I remain disappointed on several plot points and character arcs, and I’m allowed to be.

Wallpaper fantasy, figure, evening, waterfall, digital art ...

However, I don’t have the right to tell others they need to share my exact views of the series, and it certainly isn’t my responsibility, obligation, or even prerogative to force those same people to concur the author is a massive jerk.

Nor is it all right for me to tell those same people that if they can’t see she’s a massive jerk, they can go crawl in a hole and die.

This has been the defining aspect of many fandoms in recent years: which have the most division within. Harry Potter is high on that list — and now it’s been made even worse.

Realistically, the fandom as a whole is doomed. Thinking about it, though, I don’t believe that’s quite a bad thing.

As long as people keep buying them, the books will live on. But the intense in-fighting, the vicious online battle royales, will fade away. People who now stand against the author will continue to make their point known (as they should be able to). Those who don’t know or don’t care about the grievious offenses (and, yeah, I know that’s problematic, but also a discussion for another day) will carry on in liking the series, or not bothering either way.

Fantasy Art: Tea Party, by Yoshioka – Aethereal Engineer

Overall, though, we may actually go back to a bookish world where people simply read books and share their enjoyment of them. HP was one of the hugest phenoms in entertainment in the early 21st century, and it was the catalyst for a massive niche culture, there’s no denying it. We all sorted ourselves into our Hogwarts houses, found our patronuses, fit multiple references to HP into our own (utterly unrelated) WIPs. We knew whether we’d choose an owl, a toad, or a cat, what sort of wand we wanted, if we’d more likely fail Potions or Magical History. It was a big deal.

Some of us haven’t actively engaged in this part of it for a while, though, and we’re already not missing it. Maybe we’re missing it a little, but are okay with that. Others are grieving right now, and that’s permitted, too.

In the end, I’ll look back and still say I enjoyed Harry Potter. I’m going to keep my views on the books and the author separate. And I’ll support anyone who goes the opposite direction.

Though, from this moment in bookish time onward, I will appreciate if the fandom craziness of the past decade starts to quiet. Sincerely, I miss when we’d all just flail over our favorite characters in a popular series, and look forward to what came next. There’s so much disunity in the world right now, I’d really like to maintain a few spots of peace and happiness.

Maybe fandoms are something we can learn to do without.

How to Create a Haunting Fantasy Digital Art Photo Manipulation in ...

2 thoughts on “The Death of A Fandom: Could It Actually Be A Good Thing?”

  1. During my university education in the ’70s one of my professors, a young leftist professor, a child of the hippie age, lent me a copy of the novel Atlas Shrugged by the right anarchist “philosopher” Ayn Rand because he thought it would be good for me to read. I too had leftist opinions (and still do). My favourite novel at the time was Ursula K Le Guin’s The Dispossessed, which is based on left anarchism. Why would a leftist professor want a leftist student to read a novel by an ultracapitalist right wing author? We never actually talked about it, but I think I figured it out. The novel was a kind of touchstone. My leftist views would only be valid if they could survive being subjected to these dramatically opposing ideas. And they did survive. I saw through the fallacies and incorrect assumptions of Rand. But I also thoroughly enjoyed the book, the characters, the images of the story, the literary universe. I bought a copy of the book myself, and I’ve reread it at least once, endless philosophical preaching and all, and may do so again, in spite of my fundamental disagreement with the author.
    A love the HP universe. I’ve never been a mindless fan, but I respect Rowling for her literary craftsmanship and for the historical role she’s played. At a time when young people had more or less stopped reading books, she made reading cool again for new generations. The opinions she’s expressed recently has diminished my respect end sympathy for her as a person, but it hasn’t changed my respect for her craftsmanship or my love for the fictional universe she’s created. I think the HP universe is strong enough and solid enough that Rowling could exists in it and have the opinions she does – and she’d STILL BE WRONG, even in her own universe.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for your thoughts! You’re right, Atlas Shrugged is a great comparitive example. I know many on the left feel it’s a horrible book that makes clear everything wrong with all the values they think will destroy society, but that’s exactly why they want those of like mind to study it. And I’ve read plenty of other books that either had elements I totally disagreed with, or an agenda I could see from a mile away, and I still enjoyed the story. I do believe we’re rapidly coming to that point with JK Rowling. Thanks for sharing!

      Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s