In Which I Post My First Ever Comic Review!
The reason it’s a first ever is very simply because my learning disability gets in the way of how well I can consume certain media formats. Comics are notoriously one, based on their traditional layout (which means my dyslexia sometimes gets confused about who’s speaking when, or if I was supposed to read that bubble before this bubble). But the adult comics market is exploding, and thanks to my practice reading graphic novels aloud to Muffin, I am now able to navigate these waters more efficiently than in years past. And since I now belong to an author collaboration that happens to include a bunch of talented comic artists, I really want to read more and support the community more.
Anyway, I decided to start with the first release by We Have Issues, called Play It Again, which is a standalone single-issue about a man who is finishing preparing to move house after the end of a long-term relationship. Putting his young son to bed, he tries to complete the task, all the emotions of the situation weighing heavily on his heart. While packing the last few things, he finds within his record collection a vinyl disc compiled specifically of songs he wrote for his significant other at particular milestones in their lives (like moving in together, talking about getting married, finding out they were going to be parents). The man puts the record on the player, and is suddenly — literally — sucked into some sort of time-travel portal that brings him back to the moment that song references.
*Deep breath*
Okay, I don’t even know what to say without spoiling the whole story. But there is SO much I could say. For a comic you can read, without rushing, in 20 minutes, there is an INTENSE amount of raw, relatable, poignant, even brutally forthright emotion that anyone who’s ever struggled to accept “it’s over” will feel along with the narrator. The obvious parallel is to divorce or break-ups; but many of us have experienced such grief after other kinds of losses, and any situation where we’re sad, angry, confused, and barely holding it together following one pivotal event — whether we saw it coming or it’s a shock — is what creates the heart of this story.
The metaphors the narrator uses are on point, and while a little flowery at times, never leaves the realm of believable or understandable. The psychological journey he goes on while his body is literally shunted through different physical locations is tough at the beginning (think open wound bleeding), grows in letting go of guilt and forgiving oneself, and eventually reaches not just a place of acceptance, but also of warmth and love, even in the midst of heartbreak. AND. I. JUST.
Give me a minute here, everybody.
As I previously mentioned, this was the first release by the writer-artist duo that is We Have Issues; there are a few (little) things that do show up — ye olde, “wait, is that a typo?” moment; and some of the artwork looks a bit more rudimentary. HOWEVER. Because this story is also, obviously, a labor of love, the bits where maybe it could’ve used a tad more polish are easy to overlook. And it is damn impressive that two self-taught entrepreneurs (with day jobs and families and all the other things creatives so often have to juggle while producing art) put together a comic on their own, a very particular medium.
And, while, yes, I am a little biased because when I know a creator personally I just want to sing their praises, the fact I already knew a lot about these two as humans before getting into their work did not at all prepare me for what I’d find upon reading. The connection made with the reader (or maybe just this reader) feels so much stronger than what I’d expect from pen and ink. And, yes, as a writer myself, you’d think this would be a “duh” sort of musing. But, no, I was not anticipating something so resonating from a pair of since-childhood-friends who are big fans of superheroes and comics and tropes and know each other inside and out.
So, boys, thanks for wrecking me. Keep up the amazing work. And, no, I haven’t yet decided if I will try reading Deathless. I’m taking out an extended rain check on answering that question.